2406 Bayshore Rd.
Villas, NJ 08251
Why Should I Go? Cape May has some great restaurants, but if you don’t eat out EVERY night, there are some tasty alternatives. One of those is Fish and Fancy. They have a ridiculous amount of fresh and savory seafood dishes, made right there as you watch – perfect if you want to eat at home but don’t feel like cooking.
The menu is huge, so here are the highlights. On the Munchies menu, there are sweet corn fritters, broccoli bites and stuffed mushrooms. The Broiled Platters feature lump Baltimore crab cakes, jumbo stuffed shrimp and tender lobster tails. It’s hard to resist the Fried Platters — deviled crab cakes, coconut shrimp, and a large seafood combo, which includes flounder, shrimp, scallops, a deviled crab cake and a fresh breaded oyster. And don’t miss their award-winning cream of crab soup.
Insider Tip: There are plenty of veggie options, and you can order chicken by the bucket. Party trays and drop–off catering services are also available.
One of the selections from the munchies menu, this is a new starter. Served in Fish and Fancy’s signature Fra Diavalo sauce, it’s fresh and not too spicy… just right!
Seafood on the fried platter dishes is breaded daily to ensure freshness. Choose between 27 options, including stuffed flounder and popcorn shrimp.
All the soups are made daily, including the Manhattan and New England clam chowders and the cream of crab, which Fish and Fancy is known for.
Broiled Seafood Platters
There are nineteen broiled seafood options, all of which come with a baked potato, cole slaw and, if you want, a five ounce lobster tail (and who doesn’t want that?).
Fish and Fancy offers kiddy items for $3.99!